[Intro]
Hey, baby
Let me talk to you for a minute
You know you were my first love
And you're always gonna be a part of my heart
But when you walked away from me, you hurt me real bad
And God blessed me with somebody else
But now, here you come and you want me back?
But I love him
Hmm, but I know I still love you
[Verse 1]
You left me alone again
Now, return of the mack?
He came to be my friend
Now, you want me back?
I know I really love him
But I still love you
True love or one more chance?
What am I to do?
[Chorus]
Him, you
What shall I do?
Oh, no
I can't let you go, why? (Why, why)
Why, why
Can't say goodbye (Oh, no)
Man, man
I don't understand (Him or you)
Him, you
What shall I do? (What shall I do?)
Oh, no
I can't let you go, why? (Why, why)
Why, why
Can't say goodbye
Old, new
What shall I do?
[Verse 2]
You said you had to leave
I never questioned why, why
'Cause when he came to me
It filled a void inside
I don't wanna lose my baby (Woo, woo)
But I want my baby's dad
I'm so ready for my future
But I can't forget my past
[Chorus]
Him, you
What shall I do? (Tell me, baby)
Oh, no
I can't let you go, why? (Tell me why, why)
Why, why
Can't say goodbye (I don't understand)
Man, man
I don't understand (Him or you)
Him, you
What shall I do? (Oh, no)
Oh, no
I can't let you go, why? (Why, why)
Why, why
Can't say goodbye (Old and new, babe)
Old, new
Ah, aye
[Bridge]
I don't really wanna say (Oh, yeah)
Gotta get it right (Gotta get it right)
Make up my mind (Gotta make up my mind)
But I need to let you know (Hmm)
The way it is (The way it is)
Boy, what's the deal (Boy, what's the deal)
It's so confusing to my heart (I'm so confused)
The way it is? (Yes, I am)
Or the way it was?
Is it old or new?
I gotta choose
It's him or you
What shall I do? Oh, oh
[Chorus]
Him, you
What shall I do? (What shall I do?)
Oh, no
I can't let you go, why? (Why, why)
Why, why
Can't say goodbye (I don't, I don't)
Man, man
I don't understand (Him, you)
Him, you (You)
What shall I do? (Oh, no)
Oh, no
I can't let you go, why? (Can't let you go, why?)
Why, why
Can't say goodbye (Old, new)
Old, new
What shall I do?
Him, you
What shall I do? (When I love you, baby)
Oh, no
I can't let you go, why? (And I love him too)
Why, why
Can't say goodbye (Bye, bye, bye)
Man, man (Oh)
I don't understand (I don't understand)
Him, you
What shall I do? ([?], minding my own business)
Oh, no (Hangin' by yourself)
I can't let you go, why? (Oh, why?)
Why, why
Can't say goodbye (Can't say goodbye)
Old, new
What shall I do?
Him, you
What shall I do?
Oh, no
I can't let you go, why?
Why, why
Can't say goodbye
Man, man
I don't understand
Him, you
What shall I do?