Skip to content
etc.gta6Seven days in Leonida

Feature

Every GTA protagonist, ranked

Twenty-five years of car thieves, killers and very tired men, ranked on how well they hold up as people. One of the new pair is already near the top.

Words by Dan Harrison · 21 Nov 2026

For a long time the line on Grand Theft Auto protagonists was that they were coat hangers, somewhere for the player to drape their own worst impulses. That was always slightly unfair, though it was true once. It hasn’t been for ages. Somewhere between a mute bank robber in 2001 and a woman in an ankle tag in 2026, Rockstar worked out that the person in the driving seat could be the most interesting thing in the car. Looked at now, the whole run reads like a band’s back catalogue, with a few early demos, some perfectly decent B-sides and a handful of classics people still argue about in the pub.

Every lead from GTA III onwards is here, the 3D era and after, and the test is whether they work as characters: whether they want something and change along the way, and whether you’d miss them if they walked out of the story. How much fun they are to play doesn’t come into it, and nor does the quality of the game around them or the hours you lost to it. GTA VI is only days old, so Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos are judged on the set-up alone, meaning the first few hours, the trailers and the premise. No spoilers past that. One of them has still ended up very high.

Ranked

The also-rans

  1. 14. Claude

    Grand Theft Auto III, 2001

    Claude is ground zero for the modern series, and as a person he's more or less nothing at all. His girlfriend Catalina shoots him and leaves him for dead in the opening minutes of GTA III, after which he spends the entire game silently doing jobs for anyone who'll pay, and never says a word. At the time that was defensible. There's a tradition behind it, from the Man with No Name to Alain Delon's hitman in Le Samouraï, built on the idea that the less a character gives you, the more of yourself you project on to him. Then the very next games showed there was a better way to do it, and Claude was left as the answer to a pub quiz question, loved by almost nobody. He does get a silent cameo in San Andreas, bossed about by Catalina. It's the nearest he ever came to a personality, and even that one is hers. Vital to the history of the series, and that's about the end of it.

  2. 13. Toni Cipriani

    Liberty City Stories, 2005

    Toni first turned up in GTA III as a mission-giver, a Leone family heavy with a nagging mother. Liberty City Stories made him the lead of a prequel and handed the voice to Danny Mastrogiorgio. His mum is still the best thing about him. He has killed a made man, spent years in hiding and come back to a Mafia that isn't especially pleased to see him, and the game gets a modest, sitcom-ish comedy out of the fact that the scariest person in his life is the woman who keeps telling him he's a disappointment. Take her away and he's a mob film extra who got promoted above his station. Loyal, irritable, not much going on underneath.

  3. 12. Victor Vance

    Vice City Stories, 2006

    Vic Vance has the sad distinction of being written backwards. If you played Vice City you met him as a corpse, Lance's brother, killed in the ambushed deal that kicks off Tommy Vercetti's story, and Vice City Stories then went back two years to give him a life. Dorian Missick voices him as a soldier drummed out of the army after a corrupt sergeant leaves him holding the drugs, who turns to crime partly to pay for his sick brother's medical treatment. There's real pathos to be had in that, a decent man bent out of shape by his family and his circumstances, and the game does wave in its direction. Everyone already knows how Vic ends, though, and the story can't make its mind up whether to lean into that doom or ignore it. His best scene is still the one where he escorts Phil Collins to a concert so 'In the Air Tonight' can be played without anybody getting shot. Mostly that tells you about Rockstar's taste in 80s pop.

Ranked

The middle of the pack

  1. 11. Johnny Klebitz

    The Lost and Damned, 2009

    Johnny, voiced by Scott Hill, is vice-president of a biker gang called The Lost. While his president Billy Grey was away, Johnny kept the peace and did the sensible thing. Then Billy comes out of rehab and drags everyone back towards self-destruction. The steady deputy forced to pick between loyalty and survival is a terrific premise, and the first of GTA IV's two episodes gives it the grim seriousness it deserves. Johnny is also, on purpose, the least fun man in Liberty City. He's gruff and joyless and loyal, tangled up with an ex-girlfriend who is far more interesting than he is, and soaked in the same brown rock-video melancholy as the rest of the episode. In GTA V a certain Trevor Philips does for him within minutes of Trevor's own introduction, which is about as brutal as franchise housekeeping has ever got in the history of the medium. Somehow it suits him.

  2. 10. Franklin Clinton

    Grand Theft Auto V, 2013

    This one will annoy people, and annoying people is half of what lists are for. Franklin, voiced by Shawn Fonteno, is likeable and funny in small doses, he has a dog called Chop who deserves his own spin-off, and his friend Lamar steals every scene they share. He's also the protagonist GTA V has the least idea what to do with. On paper he's the hungry young man after a mentor, a repo man for a shady car dealer who wants something bigger than the streets he grew up on. In the game itself he spends most of his time as a sounding board for two older, louder men whose psychodramas are simply more vivid. Hardly anything Franklin wants exists apart from Michael or Trevor, and when the game finally hands him a proper choice, it's about which of them he'll betray. He's the bassist in a band with two lead singers. GTA Online has since given him the second act his campaign never really did.

  3. 9. Huang Lee

    Chinatown Wars, 2009

    Huang is the only lead on this list without a voice actor, and he's the funniest of the lot. He comes to Liberty City after his father's murder to hand an heirloom sword, the Yu Jian, to his uncle Kenny, and is promptly robbed, shot and left for dead. Chinatown Wars was a top-down, cel-shaded game originally made for the Nintendo DS, and it tells his whole story in text, which turns out to free it up no end. Huang is a spoilt, sarcastic rich kid dropped into a world he reckons is beneath him, and he meets every gangster, cop and lunatic with the bored, withering wit of someone who has never had to work for anything. Over the course of the game he grows up, from privileged brat to someone with a real stake in his family's mess. People forget handhelds were doing character work like that in 2009.

  4. 8. Jason Duval

    Grand Theft Auto VI, 2026

    Set-up only, and it's a lovely set-up. GTA VI opens with Jason, an ex-soldier who left the army on bad terms and now works as a fixer for a drug smuggler in the Keys called Brian Heder, doing up a house so it'll be nice for when his girlfriend gets out of prison. You can fix the roof and the wiring, fill the fridge, buy her jewellery. The series once started with a man shot by his partner, and now it starts with a man getting a home ready for one. Jason is quiet and tactical and protective, and plainly bad at saying what he feels, a type you'll know from every Michael Mann film and most country songs. Claude is the obvious comparison, another stoic professional without much to say, except that Jason's silences have actually been written, and the people around him keep trying to get him to talk. What keeps him down at eight is that he spends most of every scene standing next to Lucia, and when Lucia's in the room nobody looks anywhere else.

The series once started with a man shot by his partner, and now it starts with a man getting a home ready for one.

Ranked

The contenders

  1. 7. Luis Lopez

    The Ballad of Gay Tony, 2009

    The Ballad of Gay Tony was GTA IV's second episode, and it put the mood right. After Niko's grey melancholy and Johnny's leather-clad gloom, Rockstar went out dancing. Luis, voiced by Mario D'Leon, is bodyguard and business partner to Tony Prince, an ageing nightclub impresario buried in debt and pills, and at heart the episode is about two men from very different worlds who both happen to be in serious trouble, and what their friendship is worth. Luis is grounded and wry, devoted to his mother and his mates, and he gets dragged through billionaires, gold-plated helicopters and Liberty City nightlife with the weary patience of a man who knows this can't end well. It's Tony who lifts him. Theirs is the most tender male friendship the series has done, and an early, unfussy case of a big-budget game letting a gay character be a whole person. Luis plays the straight man in a screwball comedy, and that's often the hardest part to get right.

  2. 6. Tommy Vercetti

    Vice City, 2002

    Tommy was the first protagonist who properly talked, and he did it in Ray Liotta's voice, which is roughly like your local band's debut single arriving with a Trevor Horn production credit. Out after fifteen years in prison and sent south by the Forelli family, he loses their money and their cocaine in the botched deal that kills Vic Vance, then spends the rest of Vice City working out he'd rather own the city than apologise for losing it. He's Scarface with a better wardrobe, Goodfellas in a Hawaiian shirt, loose in a city of neon and Flash FM. The game is honest enough never to make him likeable or to redeem him. He's ambitious, short-tempered and ruthless, and his arc amounts to gradually clearing away everyone between him and the top. Set against what came later, that's thin. The performance is enormous, though, the man and the decade fit perfectly, and the moment he stops taking orders is still one of the great turns in the series. Vice City sold the 80s back to people too young to have enjoyed them first time round, and Tommy did the selling.

  3. 5. Trevor Philips

    Grand Theft Auto V, 2013

    Steven Ogg, in a filthy Sandy Shores trailer, cooking meth and shouting. Still the best performance the series has had. Trevor's soppy about his mum, oddly loyal, and when Michael sells him out it stings. Range was never his thing, though, and hour forty Trevor is just hour one Trevor with the volume up. Fifth place would make him laugh, then he'd break something.

  4. 4. Michael De Santa

    Grand Theft Auto V, 2013

    Michael is what happens when Tommy Vercetti's rise-to-the-top story reaches the top and carries on going. He's a bank robber who cut a deal with the federal authorities, faked his own death and retired to a mansion in Rockford Hills with a family who openly despise him, and Ned Luke voices him as a man whose dream came true and turned out to be miserable. He sees a therapist. He watches old films on a loop. He'd rather be anywhere than at home and can't admit it. It's The Sopranos rewritten as a midlife crisis in the Hollywood Hills, more or less, and still the sharpest and most grown-up idea GTA V had, that the American dream the series always chased might be most damning once somebody actually gets it. His scenes with his son Jimmy and his wife Amanda are some of the best domestic comedy the series has managed. As an idea for a character, nobody else has topped him. GTA V is just so crowded that his arc never lands with the weight it should, and that's what keeps him off the very top.

Jason and Lucia at sunset
Jason and Lucia: already near the topRockstar Games

Ranked

The top three

  1. 3. Carl "CJ" Johnson

    San Andreas, 2004

    "Ah shit, here we go again." Not many characters get an opening line that becomes cultural shorthand two decades later, and CJ, voiced by Young Maylay, carries the meme with good grace. He comes home to Los Santos in 1992, after five years in Liberty City, to bury his murdered mother. His old neighbourhood has been wrecked by crack and crooked cops, and he's framed almost straight away by a corrupt officer named Tenpenny, played by Samuel L. Jackson. San Andreas is a hip-hop epic in the line of Boyz n the Hood and Menace II Society, and CJ is the ideal centre for that kind of story, a decent, slightly guilty young man who left, came back and now has to prove he belongs to a family and a street that don't fully trust him any more. His brother Sweet, his sister Kendl and his friends Big Smoke and Ryder hold together a long, sprawling, often ridiculous story. Nice footnote: Shawn Fonteno, Franklin's voice, is Young Maylay's cousin, so the same family has given the series two of its most rounded Black leads. CJ is the one people grew up with, and here the nostalgia happens to be right.

  2. 2. Lucia Caminos

    Grand Theft Auto VI, 2026

    On the strength of her first few hours, Lucia is the best protagonist Rockstar has made since Niko, and most of her story is still to come. She's the first woman at the centre of a mainline GTA story in its modern form, and the game has the sense not to make that her entire personality. She's originally from Liberty City, her father trained her to fight as soon as she could walk, and she landed in Leonida Penitentiary fighting for her family. She gets out early, on parole and in an ankle tag, with a parole officer who makes it very clear the system expects her to fail, and banks that won't give her or Jason so much as a proper account. GTA has always been a satire of America, and Lucia gives it a face, someone trying to go straight in a country that keeps shutting the door. She's funny, flirty, headstrong and more calculating than she lets on, and there's a breezy confidence in the performance that pulls every scene towards her. When Jason collects her from prison, her guarded "hi" says more about years apart than a cutscene's worth of exposition could, and it's one of the best reunions in any game. Even the way she opens a door with her hip, an animation Rockstar says took months, shows how much care has gone into her. Bonnie and Clyde and Thelma & Louise are the touchstones, and it's Lucia who drives the story. By the time most players see the credits she could well be number one. She may be already.

  3. 1. Niko Bellic

    Grand Theft Auto IV, 2008

    Roman's emails promised mansions and sports cars. Niko gets off the freighter to a cramped flat over a taxi depot and a pile of his cousin's gambling debts. Michael Hollick plays him dry and tired, a veteran of the Yugoslav wars with a secret about the betrayal of his unit, and he's why GTA IV still holds up. Roman, ludicrous and loving and always on about bowling, is the best double act Rockstar has written. The cutscene remorse doesn't square with the body count, granted, but either ending lands, and Jason and Lucia owe him a lot.

    See all on Radio

    Loading track information…

    Stopped

    Choose a station

    All stations on /radio

    DORK 1LiveDork RadioDown with boring

    Listen on

    Continue listening in your music app.

    Apple MusicSpotify